Skip site navigation (1)Skip section navigation (2)
Date:      Sat, 25 Apr 2009 20:09:15 -0400
From:      "martes" <martes@mgwigglesworth.com>
To:        Steve Bertrand <steve@ibctech.ca>
Cc:        freebsd-isp@freebsd.org, martes <martes@mgwigglesworth.com>
Subject:   Re: Spamassassin anyone???
Message-ID:  <0000055048@mail.mgwigglesworth.com>
References:  <1240615371.6029.34.camel@localhost> <20090425022227.GB79909@in-addr.com> <0000054941@mail.mgwigglesworth.com> <20090425201650.GC79909@in-addr.com> <49F3737D.9030704@ibctech.ca>

Next in thread | Previous in thread | Raw E-Mail | Index | Archive | Help
>Sat Apr 25 2009 16:33:01 EDT from Steve Bertrand to Gary Palmer =20
>Subject: Re: Spamassassin anyone???
>
>Gary Palmer wrote:
>
>>> On Sat, Apr 25, 2009 at 01:59:48PM -0400, martes wrote:
>>>> Sorry if this seems like a blinded assumption, however, whenever som=
eone
>>asks
>>>> about the origin of explicit spam, such as the anti-semetic stuff th=
at
>>was
>>>> posting to the list from an obviously mangled header source, someone=

>>always
>>>> brings up that the lists are not proctared, as if there is not any
>>management
>>>> at all, and such obvious garbage is just going to post due to lack o=
f
>>>> supervision, or spam protocals...
>>>
>>> 1) Please do not top post
>>>
>>> 2) There are only two known methods for dropping 100% of spam
>>>
>>> 2a) Have a human sit and read every single e-mail and make a judgemen=
t
>>>     call that only a human can do as to the messages legitimacy.  I a=
m
>>>     not aware of any organization anywhere in the world that has
>>>     managed to get that system to scale to any volume.
>>>
>>> 2b) Turn off your SMTP server
>>>
>>> The lists are not *moderated*, other than the -announce lists and
>>> freebsd-security-notifications.  Most of the lists are open to
>>> all posters and not just list members as not everyone who wants
>>> to be involved in the project or who uses FreeBSD in some capacity
>>> subscribes to the lists.  The exception to that is freebsd-security.
>>>
>>> However do not take the lack of enforcement at the mailing list
>>> level as there being no anti-spam measures.  There are a variety
>>> of A/S measures in place that protect not only the mailing list
>>> servers but all freebsd.org e-mail addresses.
>>>
>>> If you, or anyone else, feels that they could contribute to the defea=
t
>>> of spam on the FreeBSD lists (e.g. by being an active moderator with
>>> a long-term commitment to minimising delays in posting caused by
>>> the moderation system) then please feel free to offer your services
>>> to the postmaster team.
>>

>
>Amen to every single point in every single one of your comments.
>
>I'm sure that you will provide an update with those who respond to your
>request, that have both operational qualifications, and the time to
>spare, within the coming days... :)
>
>Steve
>
>ps. apologies for the sarcasm, but this is an ISP list for ISP
>operations people (so I thought). Perhaps the FBSD mail spam system has
>a ``qualified admit'' rule or something that they could apply.
>
>Cheers Gary, keep up the great work.
>


>I simply wanted to know why every time that a bunch of racist non-sense
>comes through the list multiple times every month or so, all everyone ev=
er
>says is that there is no moderation on the list, almost like there is an=

>assumption that there is nothing being done at all.


>You guys can personally attack all you want, but I simply wanted to know=

>why  there seemed to be nothing done about this type of thing.  All I ha=
ve
>ever seen is indications that there is nothing to be done because it is=20=
a
>free, non-moderated list. No one ever responds with something like this=20=
until
>there is some intent to put someone in their place, evidently.... =20


>It is quite frustrating actualy. But hey, I have my answer now. =20


>You guys can think what you want to about my qulifications. =20


>I am sure not many of you have had to restore datacenter services while
>being shot at, or mortars coming in overhead, etc... So I am sure not
>much  would impress me either....


>Have a good day.=20
>



Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <http://docs.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?0000055048>