Date: Fri, 20 Nov 1998 15:28:01 +0100 (CET) From: Jan Conrad <conrad@dirac.physik.uni-bonn.de> To: Doug White <dwhite@resnet.uoregon.edu> Cc: freebsd-questions@FreeBSD.ORG Subject: Re: Inter FreeBSD-227 nfs mounts at boottime fail! Message-ID: <Pine.BSF.4.05.9811201502200.307-300000@merlin.physik.uni-bonn.de> In-Reply-To: <Pine.BSF.4.03.9811170912120.6774-100000@resnet.uoregon.edu>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
This message is in MIME format. The first part should be readable text, while the remaining parts are likely unreadable without MIME-aware tools. Send mail to mime@docserver.cac.washington.edu for more info. --0-1151209028-911572081=:307 Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII Hi again, On Tue, 17 Nov 1998, Doug White wrote: > On Tue, 17 Nov 1998, Jan Conrad wrote: > > > > > I am running FreeBSD-2.2.7 on six of my machines, where the standard > > > > client machine has the following fstab (excerpt) > > > > > > > > /nilles/share@dirac /nilles/share nfs rw,bg,soft,nodev 0 0 > > > > /nilles/home@dirac /nilles/home nfs rw,bg,soft,nosuid,nodev 0 0 > > > > /nilles/osf@mach /nilles/osf nfs rw,bg,soft,nodev 0 0 > > > > ... > > > The FreeBSD nfs mounts are still delayed about a minute or so... > > Try running tcpdump then try to mount your filesystems and see what's > going on. Perhaps the remote machine isn't allowing mounts from you? Well - I did the tcpdump. The keypoint seems to be that the server (dirac) also mounts a filesystem of the client. When one unmounts that filesystem before shutting down the client the problems at boottime dissappear (however it's important to have that filesystem mounted!!) As one can see from the (attached) 2nd tcpdump output, the mount of the client (merlin) fails, because the server in turn answers with a getattr while nfsd is not running at the time of the mount in /etc/rc. However, if the filesystem exported by the client is not mounted on the server (1st output), the server answers correctly. To me this seems to be a problem of FreeBSD's implementation of NFS as the problem did not appear on other UNIXes (it's nothing but a standard crossmount - I did a lot of these in the days of Ultrix 3 ;-) best regards Jan -- Physikalisches Institut der Universitaet Bonn Nussallee 12 D-53115 Bonn GERMANY --0-1151209028-911572081=:307 Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII; name="f.1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-ID: <Pine.BSF.4.05.9811201528010.307@merlin.physik.uni-bonn.de> Content-Description: filesystem not mounted Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="f.1" MTQ6NTI6MjMuMDIyMTMwIG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuYmxh Y2tqYWNrID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmRvbWFpbjogMjkz NTErIEE/IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4gKDQyKSAodHRsIDY0 LCBpZCAyKQ0KMTQ6NTI6MjMuMDIyMjgwIGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9u bi5kZS5kb21haW4gPiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmJsYWNr amFjazogMjkzNTEqIHE6IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4gMS8y LzIgZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLiBBIGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51 bmktYm9ubi5kZSAoMTQ3KSAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA1NjA5OSkNCjE0OjUyOjIz LjAyMjg5OCBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLjEwMjIgPiBkaXJh Yy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuc3VucnBjOiB1ZHAgNTYgKHR0bCA2NCwg aWQgMykNCjE0OjUyOjIzLjAyMzAwNiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4u ZGUuc3VucnBjID4gbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4xMDIyOiB1 ZHAgMjggKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNTYxMDApDQoxNDo1MjoyMy4wMjMzNjYgbWVy bGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4xMDIxID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVu aS1ib25uLmRlLnN1bnJwYzogdWRwIDU2ICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDQpDQoxNDo1 MjoyMy4wMjM0MjggZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLnN1bnJwYyA+ IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuMTAyMTogdWRwIDI4ICh0dGwg NjQsIGlkIDU2MTAxKQ0KMTQ6NTI6MjMuMDIzODc5IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsu dW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuMTAyMCA+IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS52 c2luZXQ6IHVkcCAxMTIgKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNSkNCjE0OjUyOjIzLjAyNDM5 MyBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUudnNpbmV0ID4gbWVybGluLnBo eXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4xMDIwOiB1ZHAgNjggKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNTYx MDIpDQoxNDo1MjoyMy4wMjQ5MzQgbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5k ZS41NzQxNjAwMSA+IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5uZnM6IDky IGdldGF0dHIgZmggMCwyNjMxNzIvMiAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA2KQ0KMTQ6NTI6 MjMuMDI1MDM1IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5uZnMgPiBtZXJs aW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLjU3NDE2MDAxOiByZXBseSBvayAxMTIg Z2V0YXR0ciBESVIgNzU1IGlkcyAxNTEvNDMgc3ogNTEyICAodHRsIDY0LCBp ZCA1NjEwNSkNCjE0OjUyOjIzLjAyNTYyMyBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1i b25uLmRlLjU3NDE2MDAyID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5m czogOTIgZnNpbmZvIFt8bmZzXSAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA3KQ0KMTQ6NTI6MjMu MDI1NjkzIGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5uZnMgPiBtZXJsaW4u cGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLjU3NDE2MDAyOiByZXBseSBvayAxNjQgZnNp bmZvIFBPU1Q6IERJUiA3NTUgaWRzIDE1MS80MyBzeiA1MTIgbmxpbmsgMTEg cmRldiAzLzIzMiBmc2lkIDMwMDAwMDBlOCBub2RlaWQgZTgwMDAwMDAwMCBh L20vY3RpbWUgOTExNTIzNjEwLjAwMDAwMCA5MDk4NDg1OTEuMDAwMDAwIDkw OTg0ODU5MS4wMDAwMDAgIFt8bmZzXSAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA1NjEwNikNCjE0 OjUyOjIzLjAyNjEyNCBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLjU3NDE2 MDAzID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZnNzdGF0 IGZoIDAsMjYzMTcyLzIgKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgOCkNCjE0OjUyOjIzLjAyNjE5 NSBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUubmZzID4gbWVybGluLnBoeXNp ay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS41NzQxNjAwMzogcmVwbHkgb2sgMTY4IGZzc3RhdCBQ T1NUOiBESVIgNzU1IGlkcyAxNTEvNDMgc3ogNTEyIG5saW5rIDExIHJkZXYg My8yMzIgZnNpZCAzMDAwMDAwZTggbm9kZWlkIGU4MDAwMDAwMDAgYS9tL2N0 aW1lIDkxMTUyMzYxMC4wMDAwMDAgOTA5ODQ4NTkxLjAwMDAwMCA5MDk4NDg1 OTEuMDAwMDAwICBbfG5mc10gKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNTYxMDcpDQo= --0-1151209028-911572081=:307 Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII; name="f.2" Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-ID: <Pine.BSF.4.05.9811201528011.307@merlin.physik.uni-bonn.de> Content-Description: filesystem mounted Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="f.2" MTQ6NDA6MTguMDk2NjkyIG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuYmxh Y2tqYWNrID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmRvbWFpbjogNDM5 NjUrIEE/IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4gKDQyKSAodHRsIDY0 LCBpZCAyKQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguMDk2ODQ4IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9u bi5kZS5kb21haW4gPiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmJsYWNr amFjazogNDM5NjUqIHE6IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4gMS8y LzIgZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLiBBIGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51 bmktYm9ubi5kZSAoMTQ3KSAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA1MzYyMikNCjE0OjQwOjE4 LjA5NzQ3OCBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLjEwMjIgPiBkaXJh Yy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuc3VucnBjOiB1ZHAgNTYgKHR0bCA2NCwg aWQgMykNCjE0OjQwOjE4LjA5NzY2MiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4u ZGUuc3VucnBjID4gbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4xMDIyOiB1 ZHAgMjggKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNTM2MjMpDQoxNDo0MDoxOC4wOTgwMjEgbWVy bGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS4xMDIxID4gZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVu aS1ib25uLmRlLnN1bnJwYzogdWRwIDU2ICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDQpDQoxNDo0 MDoxOC4wOTgwODcgZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLnN1bnJwYyA+ IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuMTAyMTogdWRwIDI4ICh0dGwg NjQsIGlkIDUzNjI0KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguMDk4NTM1IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsu dW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuMTAyMCA+IGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS52 c2luZXQ6IHVkcCAxMTIgKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNSkNCjE0OjQwOjE4LjA5ODgx NyBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuZDk2MTRjMGMgPiBtZXJsaW4u cGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZ2V0YXR0ciBmaCAwLDEzMTA3 NS8yICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDUzNjI1KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguMDk5MDg4IG1lcmxp bi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgPiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4u ZGU6IGljbXA6IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgdWRwIHBvcnQg bmZzZCB1bnJlYWNoYWJsZSAodHRsIDI1NSwgaWQgNikNCjE0OjQwOjE4LjE0 NjA3NiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuZDk2MTRjMGMgPiBtZXJs aW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZ2V0YXR0ciBmaCAwLDEz MTA3NS8yICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDUzNjI2KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguMTQ2MzM2IG1l cmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgPiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJv bm4uZGU6IGljbXA6IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgdWRwIHBv cnQgbmZzZCB1bnJlYWNoYWJsZSAodHRsIDI1NSwgaWQgNykNCjE0OjQwOjE4 LjIzNjA3NyBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuZDk2MTRjMGMgPiBt ZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZ2V0YXR0ciBmaCAw LDEzMTA3NS8yICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDUzNjI3KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguMjM2MzM1 IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgPiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5p LWJvbm4uZGU6IGljbXA6IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgdWRw IHBvcnQgbmZzZCB1bnJlYWNoYWJsZSAodHRsIDI1NSwgaWQgOCkNCjE0OjQw OjE4LjQwNjA3NSBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuZDk2MTRjMGMg PiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZ2V0YXR0ciBm aCAwLDEzMTA3NS8yICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDUzNjI4KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTguNDA2 MzM1IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgPiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsu dW5pLWJvbm4uZGU6IGljbXA6IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUg dWRwIHBvcnQgbmZzZCB1bnJlYWNoYWJsZSAodHRsIDI1NSwgaWQgOSkNCjE0 OjQwOjE4LjczNjA4NiBkaXJhYy5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuZDk2MTRj MGMgPiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLm5mczogOTIgZ2V0YXR0 ciBmaCAwLDEzMTA3NS8yICh0dGwgNjQsIGlkIDUzNjMxKQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTgu NzM2MzQ2IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUgPiBkaXJhYy5waHlz aWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGU6IGljbXA6IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4u ZGUgdWRwIHBvcnQgbmZzZCB1bnJlYWNoYWJsZSAodHRsIDI1NSwgaWQgMTAp DQoxNDo0MDoxOS4zODYwODYgZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmQ5 NjE0YzBjID4gbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5uZnM6IDkyIGdl dGF0dHIgZmggMCwxMzEwNzUvMiAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA1MzYzMykNCjE0OjQw OjE5LjM4NjM0NyBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlID4gZGlyYWMu cGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlOiBpY21wOiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1i b25uLmRlIHVkcCBwb3J0IG5mc2QgdW5yZWFjaGFibGUgKHR0bCAyNTUsIGlk IDExKQ0KMTQ6NDA6MTkuNTA1OTcyIGF2encwMi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4u ZGUuNDYxOCA+IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuY2Zpbmdlcjog UyAxMjEyNzM2MDAwOjEyMTI3MzYwMDAoMCkgd2luIDE2Mzg0IDxtc3MgMTQ2 MD4gKHR0bCA2MCwgaWQgMTcwOTgpDQoxNDo0MDoxOS41MDYxMDIgYXJwIHdo by1oYXMgYXZ6dzAyLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZSB0ZWxsIG1lcmxpbi5w aHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUNCjE0OjQwOjE5LjUwNzA2NSBhcnAgcmVwbHkg YXZ6dzAyLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZSBpcy1hdCBhYTowOjQ6MDo0Nzpm NA0KMTQ6NDA6MTkuNTA3MTY3IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUu Y2ZpbmdlciA+IGF2encwMi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUuNDYxODogUiAw OjAoMCkgYWNrIDEyMTI3MzYwMDEgd2luIDAgKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgMTIpDQox NDo0MDoyMC42NzYxMDggZGlyYWMucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlLmQ5NjE0 YzBjID4gbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5uZnM6IDkyIGdldGF0 dHIgZmggMCwxMzEwNzUvMiAodHRsIDY0LCBpZCA1MzY2MCkNCjE0OjQwOjIw LjY3NjM2OSBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlID4gZGlyYWMucGh5 c2lrLnVuaS1ib25uLmRlOiBpY21wOiBtZXJsaW4ucGh5c2lrLnVuaS1ib25u LmRlIHVkcCBwb3J0IG5mc2QgdW5yZWFjaGFibGUgKHR0bCAyNTUsIGlkIDEz KQ0KMTQ6NDA6MjMuMjQ2MTIxIGRpcmFjLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZS5k OTYxNGMwYyA+IG1lcmxpbi5waHlzaWsudW5pLWJvbm4uZGUubmZzOiA5MiBn ZXRhdHRyIGZoIDAsMTMxMDc1LzIgKHR0bCA2NCwgaWQgNTM2NjEpDQoxNDo0 MDoyMy4yNDYzODMgbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZSA+IGRpcmFj LnBoeXNpay51bmktYm9ubi5kZTogaWNtcDogbWVybGluLnBoeXNpay51bmkt Ym9ubi5kZSB1ZHAgcG9ydCBuZnNkIHVucmVhY2hhYmxlICh0dGwgMjU1LCBp ZCAxNCkNCg== --0-1151209028-911572081=:307-- To Unsubscribe: send mail to majordomo@FreeBSD.org with "unsubscribe freebsd-questions" in the body of the message
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?Pine.BSF.4.05.9811201502200.307-300000>