Date: Tue, 15 Jan 2002 17:00:39 +0100 From: Martin Kraemer <Martin.Kraemer@Fujitsu-Siemens.com> To: freebsd-isdn@freebsd.org Subject: FW: ISDN4BSD not ready for prime time in 4.5-RC ? Message-ID: <20020115170039.A1324@deejai2.mch.fsc.net>
next in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
--SLDf9lqlvOQaIe6s Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Disposition: inline After I sent this mail I still tried the following: * reduced the "raw b" channels from 8 to 4 * cvsup'ed * talked with another freebsd-isdn user who has the same card as I have Still I am unsure what actually goes wrong here. Will isdntrace help me to pinpoint the trouble? I cannot make much sense from its output (attached). These come together with repeated syslog messages like... Jan 15 15:55:20 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 15 15:55:20 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 15 15:55:24 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_mph_status_ind: unit 0, persistent deactivation! Jan 15 15:55:24 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 i4b_mdl_status_ind: STI_PDEACT: unit 0 TEI = 0 = 0x00 Jan 15 15:56:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 15 15:56:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 15 16:23:53 deejai2 /kernel: i4b: unit 0, assigned TEI = 81 = 0x51 Jan 15 16:24:37 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error see <<messages.gz>>. What else can I check (short of putting a second card into my PC -- problematic because of lack of irq's...)? Can it still be that the NTBA is broken? Martin -- <Martin.Kraemer@Fujitsu-Siemens.com> | Fujitsu Siemens Fon: +49-89-636-46021, FAX: +49-89-636-47655 | 81730 Munich, Germany --SLDf9lqlvOQaIe6s Content-Type: message/rfc822 Content-Disposition: inline Date: Fri, 11 Jan 2002 16:48:10 +0100 From: Martin Kraemer <Martin.Kraemer@Fujitsu-Siemens.com> To: freebsd-stable@freebsd.org Subject: ISDN4BSD not ready for prime time in 4.5-RC ? Message-ID: <20020111164810.A568@deejai2.mch.fsc.net> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Disposition: inline User-Agent: Mutt/1.2.5i X-Operating-System: FreeBSD 4.5-RC FreeBSD 4.5-RC X-Organization: Fujitsu Siemens Computers (Muenchen, Germany) X-Disclaimer: THE COMMENTS CONTAINED IN THIS MESSAGE REFLECT THE VIEWS OF THE WRITER AND ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE VIEWS OF FUJITSU-SIEMENS COMPUTERS X-No-Junk-Mail: I do not want to get *any* junk mail. Hello, In 4.5-RC (more exact, since ~October), I cannot succeed in using ISDN any more. Yes I changed the cable, and I asked a friend to use ISDN on the same NTBA (from Win2k), to the same provider I use; he had no problems. Only my machine, which used to be ISDN'ing rock-solidly, is unusable, and each connection is broken and torn down after a few packets' exchange between my machine and my provider. In 4.2, 4.3 and 4.4-RELEASE, I used a Teles Teles S0/16.3 ISA (non-PnP) card. Because I noticed the ISDN problems, I brought a Fritz!Card PCI 1.0 and tested that, but to no avail: both experience the same symptoms. OTOH I don't want to go back to FreeBSD-4.3 only for ISDN..... I have the following ISDN configuration in my kernel: --snip-- options TEL_S0_16_3 device isic0 at isa? port 0xd80 irq 5 flags 3 device ifpi pseudo-device "i4bq921" pseudo-device "i4bq931" pseudo-device "i4b" pseudo-device "i4btrc" 8 pseudo-device "i4bctl" pseudo-device "i4brbch" 8 pseudo-device "i4btel" 2 pseudo-device "i4bipr" 8 options IPR_VJ pseudo-device "i4bisppp" 8 --snip-- (Is there a problem with using 8 instead of 4?) I cvsup'ed to 4.5-RC today -- using a modem :-( I noticed there was a patch in the i4bisppp code, but the problems haven't changed. For TELES 16.3: Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: isic0 at port 0xd80-0xd9f,0x980-0x99f,0x180-0x19f,0x580-0x59f irq 5 flags 0x3 on isa0 Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: isic0: passive stack unit 0 Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: isic0: Teles S0/16.3 Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4bctl: ISDN system control port attached Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4btrc: 8 ISDN trace device(s) attached Jan 11 15:44:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4bisppp: 8 ISDN SyncPPP device(s) attached (VJ header compression) Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b: ISDN call control device attached Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4btel: 2 ISDN telephony interface device(s) attached Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4brbch: 8 raw B channel access device(s) attached Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4bipr: 8 IP over raw HDLC ISDN device(s) attached (VJ header compression) ... Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_T202_timeout: unit 0, N202 = 3 Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 T303_timeout: SETUP not answered, cr = 68 Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 next_l3state: FSM illegal state, state = ST_OW - Out Wait EST, event = EV_T303EXP - T303 timeout! Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 15:44:42 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 15:45:47 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 F_ILL: FSM function F_ILL executing Jan 11 15:45:47 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_next_l2state: FSM illegal state, state = ST_EST_AW_TEI, event = EV_DLESTRQ! Jan 11 15:45:52 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 T303_timeout: SETUP not answered, cr = 24 Jan 11 15:45:52 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 next_l3state: FSM illegal state, state = ST_OW - Out Wait EST, event = EV_T303EXP - T303 timeout! ... Jan 11 16:25:31 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:25:31 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:25:43 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:25:43 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:26:04 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:26:04 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:26:14 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:26:14 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:26:14 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:26:14 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 isic_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:26:17 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_mph_status_ind: unit 0, persistent deactivation! Jan 11 16:26:17 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 i4b_mdl_status_ind: STI_PDEACT: unit 0 TEI = 0 = 0x00 and with the Fritz!Card: Jan 11 16:12:43 deejai2 /kernel: ifpi0: <AVM Fritz!Card PCI> port 0xe800-0xe81f mem 0xfedfac00-0xfedfac1f irq 9 at device 16.0 on pci0 Jan 11 16:12:43 deejai2 /kernel: ifpi0: ISAC 2085 Version A1/A2 or 2086/2186 Version 1.1 (IOM-2) Jan 11 16:12:43 deejai2 /kernel: ifpi0: passive stack unit 0 ... Jan 11 16:15:55 deejai2 isdnd[476]: DMN init_controller_state: controller 0 is AVM Fritz!Card PCI Jan 11 16:15:55 deejai2 isdnd[476]: DMN i4b isdn daemon started (pid = 476) Jan 11 16:16:01 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_ph_data_req: No Space in TX FIFO, state = F4 Awaiting Signal Jan 11 16:16:01 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:16:03 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_T202_timeout: unit 0, N202 = 3 Jan 11 16:16:03 deejai2 /kernel: i4b: unit 0, assigned TEI = 73 = 0x49 Jan 11 16:16:03 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:18:54 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:19:59 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:19:59 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:20:02 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:20:02 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:20:02 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:20:02 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:20:02 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error ...etc... Jan 11 16:20:40 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: CRC error Jan 11 16:20:40 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: unit 0: Receive Aborted error Jan 11 16:20:40 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L1 ifpi_isac_irq: RPF, input buffer overflow! Jan 11 16:20:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L2 i4b_mph_status_ind: unit 0, persistent deactivation! Jan 11 16:20:41 deejai2 /kernel: i4b-L3 i4b_mdl_status_ind: STI_PDEACT: unit 0 TEI = 0 = 0x00 Anybody seeing a light? Helpless, Martin -- <Martin.Kraemer@Fujitsu-Siemens.com> | Fujitsu Siemens Fon: +49-89-636-46021, FAX: +49-89-636-47655 | 81730 Munich, Germany --SLDf9lqlvOQaIe6s Content-Type: application/x-gunzip Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="isdntrace0-20020115-162329.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 H4sICJpKRDwCA2lzZG50cmFjZTAtMjAwMjAxMTUtMTYyMzI5AO1cbXPaVhb+7l9xUm+6dmqU +36vPEunju1k2KaOa5PZDzv7QUjCZYoxBdwmM5n97XvuRYAweiXIzjbVAMYCXT3n7TnnXh20 115tMJhGo9kkCGMI7/DN3XAYT2CfQPo701kwmcURdO9j+GcwAiqBqmPGj5kPjBC2t9dqQfe8 9f1FF1pwPxrMjgm0HmwwG9zGx1R6hCZHS+5Rpn2fbXy3tdcRnBxD5+L1OwoHJ+Fs8HswG9yN 4Cr+7T6ezo7gcjK4mwxmH6EN5gj6k7tbRHCYjQQ/DvDcxG4UipHAMB7dzH45NgmovbP727E9 FKAfQr8PhAPpg2IQKsABcE/x5uHWw+fezz6jx3B9ctlWHA66553WT8EouIlv49Hs8AhOjxB4 p404juBq0CYfQqXYEXSipcgnA/upE/Gi2/q+e15X2Ur7hhYqm8HBZTyKBqMbWCk9Ue9F9/Az zm20r3XhucXS0HG0bt+XfhmEtIVZjoUZQQglFo43LMwg4E1b+GQ6HdyMnIENLXdhXlFAvikg PlEcXeazmwKmZCNwcBoMh3A654uVYIYewfvWawcUv/nqp3O4fA0Uyk0m8iSiKJGqIhGvK9G0 UKKrDInen6TEKTSQrCpO4oIb4uCr/aeOgSpbqLOQ5+Lg+hAI/rmyfy7xucAhEIex5CY0oDAB BdyFkWAM+ASo+8hwUCEQH5BRuFrieOMttqHnqWRAhrJwDdwHzoAT9+oemixGmO/n7tV9Yb5p nxHG2NhD5+Y208wHtCe0X5NQdyMS9cRRT+Oo/bOH7152PCFRLeEEAxLlPXBEg9RzMxg59kPt 3cbTKYZx+/q8+/7yGPbcSP+eJkQZ3t2Oh/Es/k+yvxcHE8yhYTAOeoMhUtjiCLfh7vb9aIKE PhmENqlGeKZZMITBqH83uXWnTH19Oovap6edbje1b4IM2VYCfu0NZi+nqQ9u76K4HQ4m4f1g tkAT/hKMRjEOHx1D8r4djD4u3sPBeBL348kkjg6Xh6DvWMHGmPU/wuj+thdPjkEltoCD2cdx jDL8Orr7A0lrPAxG7c712cXa8SjY+uFz+6E3FRxeyhMqL7CE9pVYBZbI4wk8iLBdBlaKKK4X gXV1NQ8qavmCVKA/nSOW0NrHaFuKRekmX7AFX7DH5AuazRehtjgSgvCr4ZhDKQ/JCENmMyRP T96+hcurd6fn52edizfL4Mxy+1ctrCXjD+Hwfjr4PU78rZDITUXDZPkb+3L9zc8US3pcacnT /ibz/I09lr/RUn/TgLMQ5BWLidrCjWKK0vk4Dj/f595dXJyfdpe+FiEfv3T6BKdQz8aA1Wm5 h1FS0RQml9GYTc6PaAqWXyr0a+F4431GKk5sACenP168+9fb87M358flnk9pnrq1loJUTCDi sQKapQJ6i0mt9qjWVPOUWIsE8oolEx432wkJMOpEo1ZMJhMxMaqi0MWWgn4Pgngl1DN8Pl+U em44dGVQyhaI9kjjBpVJJYt694V9XQ5KUwzS99KDJcPZmpFyWx4Sl99weNEDKSEUtg4tSyo/ vsdxtpwqot581FvKHagp1htzeiOxwyrcfp7ojaHegrTenjl8+5733UpvmkKP165lf6sgIa8o IeNFEorEM9Agm0acW2nNM7wNz6hrxOVwS0MWBoDIERNnXFSZqoZkT2vILeaUmxIKVSRhmAQk C5KAnkeslnYGrfCVrRvyhef1vftpPFlKyCI7a5s/mJupsdhO3JJX3Gns0gmOqHw7Q5xvrfF4 DMzjHoeD3v1guAxxLewxIgBFQcXueGLnivOhl7NBtl5MztwyJGi3+lhh0U/lKY+h8mQqClQJ PzLnxaoaP3o1+TFvW/HjtlMJlJTXkZR9GZJuUZujpEpTmQoIyXIllWtBQHIeS0mf22DYZDZS 9uDZw3kbimN5w2FQr/6lqfdyfbjXa8Px9HC9sG7VUmoBv6IFSimJfn2UlFP4o/KwZJPpQBW5 yuOrko0KG5kKFaGBU7swZqFSG31L5e07z7j9g0pGV+67v5/9KN72k23bilt7ytdE05Wc/qLi zpSTLdxeliyMLuUst0Be8Ye4yFrxl20BQ6AfrSxAAqCBJTxtFlHKstY6cPtQCV5e5WbrtvQi MiN58NI1PZ3zkIIAyzYfdAhx6NSqMpj80wN+wwDDuR0OVINBWhWyFc0r2zTTZC1bkSIGMcBY ImOeUVIyfpORrfJsVrx9qJKRaV7hZjAAmF/FzeZ2RGacSzS3Y8ghclkhlA/dLJWRy90srzTy SR14rCl4GfWMwE88zZVI55j/5ygweTIKlFFXNYFY+fxcojzIKRlbVUzg58GTCE/WSPPs60vz jOQpT6HyePXonytvGV5p/80Lr0/lrsdoHjyN8GhVePwhvCT6BdDoc6KfsTx4RglRgzuTEnwL eIXa45nwmMeEolJUh9cjTXAnE3nwZB14rCl4MhMe97QvjaBPblyVA8+QevB6dFvtFcLTO4HH GtIezY5c6VEj0fsqXjmTDV3XyF5or9DZQfkXJ9ZVRbEKnSm7AlE4k5dc1CEy1oivZ1cgBufK whekBjzeBDyemeMp8ZjBFK9rwBM7g1fSkofwqMeo4MIUtuShu13cwfXgZhQMD7c/E+eCL9Yx HrHxcH5ugefmj9F4SDPzrYUg5xCKutiYnbfK2l1s11UojzKVamM761yfFvFCJaUqlIg8kUG1 4NQ8hkF5ZnVMsYDyBeV1SgDZCO9k5liqPE45Z6wGPN0IvMxcSY2H2Na7msrgmcejRWZpkXHe PC0yS4uM06egRXtuged+HFrMrPMtBIkQ6J+GFq1EinHiP5FBy8+9K1rMzHOMWX+mtA7vBI3w Tra/CXR5qkkd3uk1Ai9zXsmQtSXlRNaAFzYCL3NeyZC1FfFJnVo7ejzW5pa1MR82z9p4Jm47 mZ+Cte25BZ5bPQprZ7qphSARgvnTsLaVSBEXeE9i0PJz74q1M+f4HGnR+MrUoMWwkdVAnjnH 59Izyuc+r7FYSZuAJ0gOPF/7XMsa16HE2nWo9HJb3nUob4fXoQplzJzucOUR4nNVZ72YNWIC lgcP/UPWuFK5/SpQITy+K3iiEXhiV/BkI/BkHjyB8HQNeLoReGpX8Ewj8PSu4AWNwDO7gtdr BJ6/K3hhE/AkyYMnEZ6sAS9qBB6tCM9kt14TB08s+kOlsG2ZUbxofHRdOUrbtoEVvHPP69ou 0R+8mxfLzJi+JJ6WjbiQoxpMaHsDiHzQh/lpKet9ug/T+ICOgbTJQ1tTxHLRXmHcbxJQiz3X 1BC5bvHFL1+8ztk/NvK27cOkrvWVum55NJS7g4IFRY1FTQOgPaChLQNoDLRf1CUqbC+E0xpj tjmOOZUxBUzbFgh7T4bAdquz0JYKLAa2/F3Os2/2//b8278fHL747qjlvXTDSTL/Le38R7gc cHpv2weV7YUo+S0tZVxIpct9JDt1+5h8jE5fif7Cq6ei+lryPBkFylhjVSRs5HqxFDuBJxIT 7LrJSMo8eMpoYaqTXNhI+S9VRXilPVD86+uBkjpPeRqVV+P6KJFNtCpIkwfP1IHHPgNeofYy qxNBPEqN5P42+VW5rsdUfg21daD1/Pqty68p7kzLs5lfsXLsEVd9y2q/cwj0Kr8GkVtVYH/l 1/z8Wn95SVCPEcOprrkqWuSNKrMYFfaqrGFGbeONBsJg3RslSPLAGw/m3nhZ3Rt9bhVMVK43 6rQ39lLVHrpMFC38+C9vrFbtlXuj9JBPeck9oHZ7s6/s7vEUkoo3+4owX8vKN/vytrkVVF9G Qd7NvrZQtkYRla/lYyo7M4+mkFRUto4hqq7s/26j7EjqOEvZ/wPVuVsTGU8AAA== --SLDf9lqlvOQaIe6s Content-Type: application/x-gunzip Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="messages.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 H4sICDVLRDwCA21lc3NhZ2VzAO2WXW/aMBSG7/crzu6plk+CLPUiY1Rrt7aoydZK0xS5yYF5 Cw61DW3//Rzot6AN4GprawkIguTJ856c42SPcnBD/SJhSNw2FIi/KfPgwx8UHEsCLDjd+uoC kyzPmKT6Q5wRmHCmwCHQPeoCClGJd3ubgY4wRzZFiE8robBYBPUcQ3arg5rYBUugXr3JRuNf mVRUTWTGeHFNbsEYhWRSIVf6cJorNqWKVfx9Q7g/hxflPXiS7mb9T724m16fCNLeLmzrrX5f OM5depsErpHCrgN6vLBt4vkk9BdCb0tIpWRDrg+eZ+y4s5ChexcTED/aPOSaoCdDBiTwnqd7 Hodv2j0P6UwWvPjhOp2fBI6PDmAkhxnN82rCFeNDAryCvOIDNgRtLC5hoP8pHsp2lpZXsREK P8OLMROoRWtp1E47AcTnlNXngES3Ai0bI2dXTGBeTVEQ+Jx0T+Ajgd0kjedZ1wSBRsRdA6Ab o/04+TIjDQaboOJ7qM6m8W5QHm2Imvdz6jleVl/OaqJuu/lA/6pp/mpWejQKqqi2O6tbgpUl MH7VGzv+g+4KnaWjkPqOf+uU9NJvfd2wCiiX56j7rQW50HZR1JjI8UJlpT9TIbCT7IOWwyEt 53atmwZO0uzwGLbgcKLgWDcy9JK0BTit53obet+z2q130te71N/gyrJptvUnJ3QMTU5j0FOT s7rR0slZDfXo5Kweb8nkhCQIjdyn1gE9eZ/S0LYpu/brsnvpMUsqFYxQSjpEEDhGWp/cm60c 8nVfOmtn7azdOnaRKbvI2lk7a/dC7RY/O0QLnx1sxZ+v4t5bqPgbGWW7Ylk7a2fHy8a0Me3K 8cLsOqbsOtbu1dut8iz/HJlCx1Cm0LF21q65nWvK7t+BmsT0TNl51u7/svNN2fnG7SLibDD8 fwHhmYiFFSgAAA== --SLDf9lqlvOQaIe6s-- To Unsubscribe: send mail to majordomo@FreeBSD.org with "unsubscribe freebsd-isdn" in the body of the message
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?20020115170039.A1324>