Date: Fri, 17 Aug 2007 10:57:49 -0600 From: "Kirk Davis" <kirk.davis@epsb.ca> To: "Craig Boston" <cb@severious.net> Cc: freebsd-usb@freebsd.org Subject: RE: (Please test) New blackberry (uberry) driver. Message-ID: <DB9A31C316524A4A83E54A2C0D2065576E45B9@Exchange24.EDU.epsb.ca> References: <DB9A31C316524A4A83E54A2C0D2065570413BCD2@Exchange24.EDU.epsb.ca> <20070809200142.GB80751@nowhere> <20070809212655.GD80751@nowhere>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
Hi Craig,
Thanks for testing the driver. Sorry it has taken a little =
while to get back to you. I have been camping in Ontario, Canada with =
very intermittent internet access.=20
=20
I have tested it with an 8830, 8100, and an 8703e but nit with =
the 8700 so far. I'll have to look around work and I'm sure I can dig =
up an 8700 to test with.
=20
Are you sure that it is charging at 500mA rate without the =
do_charge routing in there? You can check this with the 'usbdevs -v' =
command. It should show 500mA power rate. The problem with the =
Blackberries is that they do not tell the USB bus to turn on the 500mA =
charge until you enable it on the device. Then the device disconnects =
and reconnects to the buss with the higher charge rate enabled. That =
might be why you are seeing it detach and reattach. =20
=20
It gets even harder with the "pearl" type Blackberry. I'm not =
yet sure what models have the "pearl" features in them but it seems like =
it was added for a removable storage card. The 8100 (the real pearl), =
8800, and the 8830 all have this feature. When these devices connect to =
the buss, they id themselves as a pearl type blackberry. The driver then =
needs to turn on the high charge rate and tell them to go into dual =
mode. The dual mode allows them to charge and also expose the memory =
card to the umass USB driver so it can be mounted.=20
=20
There is still one bug that I am tracking down and that is in the =
way the umass device is handling the memory card. The blackberry =
exposes the memory card to the umass device right away but doesn't let =
it use it until the user types in there password on the blackberry. The =
umass device does like this tries to repeatedly query the card. Once =
you type the password in then everything seems to be OK. I'm sure it's =
just a matter of setting up the right QUIRKS string in the umass driver =
but I haven't yet had a chance to start working on this.
=20
Any more feedback or testing is always welcome.
=20
--- Kirk
________________________________
From: Craig Boston [mailto:cb@severious.net]
Sent: Thu 8/9/2007 3:26 PM
To: Kirk Davis
Subject: Re: (Please test) New blackberry (uberry) driver.
On Thu, Aug 09, 2007 at 03:01:42PM -0500, Craig Boston wrote:
> After those changes it compiled cleanly, but unfortunately it doesn't
> work quite right with my 8700. It gets detected, but continually
> detaches and reattaches.
A quick followup to my last message, if I comment out the do_charge
stuff completely it no longer detaches and reattaches constantly. So it
appears that on the 8700 at least, the only change from the OpenBSD
version that is necessary to enable 500mA charging is changing
UBERRY_CONFIG_NO from 0 to 1.
Craig
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?DB9A31C316524A4A83E54A2C0D2065576E45B9>